NewsLocal News


Grandfather found guilty of homicide in deadly beating of grandson

Posted at 4:56 PM, May 05, 2022
and last updated 2022-05-05 18:28:38-04

MILWAUKEE — The grandfather of 12-year-old Andre Smith II was found guilty of first degree intentional homicide for beating Andre to death in August of last year.

Andrez Martina accused Andre of stealing money from his wallet and "lost control," authorities say.

Martina was found guilty of multiple charges including first-degree intentional homicide, physical abuse of a child, and possession of a firearm by a felon. Sentencing is scheduled for Monday, June 6.

The cause of death is listed as multiple blunt force injuries to the head.

The criminal complaint states Martina asked Andre and his brother, 8 years old, to sleep over at his house. Martina planned to take to the boys shopping for school supplies the next day.

 Andre Smith II
Andre Smith II

In the morning, the grandmother says the defendant sent her a text accusing Andre of stealing his money. The grandmother asked where Andre was and the defendant replied, "he's bleeding."

That's when the grandmother woke her daughter and her boyfriend and told them to go to the defendant's house near 46th and Glendale and find out what was happening.

There they found the boys and the defendant. The boyfriend immediately drove the boys to the hospital. Andre was unconscious with a severe head wound.

Andre and his brother's disabled great grandmother, who lives with Martina, told police she was awakened by the defendant yelling at Andre. She looked up and saw the defendant hitting Andre with a hammer, according to the complaint.


Police say they found methamphetamine pills, marijuana and a firearm in the defendant's home.

At the hospital, police learned the 8-year-old brother suffered a head laceration, fractured finger and bruising consistent with child physical abuse. The brother told investigators that Martina was angry about missing money and beat the brothers with a mallet, a sledge hammer, and a coat rack.

In an interview with police, Martina said he returned to Milwaukee from Indiana in May. "Upon returning to Milwaukee, the defendant wanted to reconnect with his grandchildren. The defendant learned [Andre] had a problem stealing," according to the complaint.

The defendant recalled telling his grandchildren in the past, “if you lie, if you mess up in school, if you steal, I’m going to kill you."

During the interview, the defendant also admitted to killing another boy in 1989 and "said he wanted to talk with police as the defendant has nothing to hide," the complaint states.

TMJ4 does not typically use mugshots in our coverage but does in specific instances, including high-profile cases like this one.

Report a typo or error // Submit a news tip