"Israel said Peterson should have 'went in addressed the killer, killed the killer…when we at law enforcement arrive at an active shooter we go in and address the target.”
Diamond wants to know if Peterson was properly trained. He says the officer worked in one of the safest cities in the country in one of the highest rated high schools in Florida.
“Whether or not his training was adequate or not is in question, whether or not his physical condition and his confidence was to where it should be, is in question,” Diamond said. “Now, he’s got a situation coming down around his ears and you expect him to run in without anybody to cover his back, I mean that is unrealistic.”
But, that is exactly how the sheriff said Peterson should’ve reacted.
When asked by reporters to describe how the video made him feel, Israel responded, "sick to my stomach" and "devastated."
"It doesn’t matter who went in first, it doesn’t matter in what order you went in," he said. "What matters is that when we in law enforcement arrive at an active shooter, we go in and address the target and that’s what should have been done."
Peterson was named school resource officer of the year in the city of Parkland in 2014, after he had been with the school for five years, records show. According to a booklet announcing the award, Peterson had "proven to be reliable in handling issues with tact and judgment" and was active in mentoring and counseling students that year.
Two other deputies were placed on restricted duty while the sheriff's office investigates whether they "could've" or "should've" done more while dealing with suspect, 19-year-old Nikolas Cruz, amid the 23 calls they received involving Cruz or his brother since 2008, Israel said.
Of those calls, investigators feel that two cases "deserve extra scrutiny" to see if there was a policy violation by the deputies involved.
Israel also said school resource officers will now be equipped with visible AR-15’s on campus. That decision was made after the shooting. Diamond points out that also shows Peterson was outgunned from the start: armed with only a handgun.
“I think this is such a volatile and tragic scenario that everybody, everybody is going to overreact, everyone’s going to look at somebody to put the finger on… I think it's inappropriate, I think that’s scapegoating the deputy,” Diamond said.
There are also questions about why a tip to the FBI about Cruz fell through the cracks. Diamond says taking all of the failures in their totality don't fall on one deputy.
"The cop on the scene is wrong, I don’t care what happens, if it doesn’t turn out successfully," Diamond said. "And, I’m afraid in this scenario, that’s what’s happening."