Former Milwaukee Police officer Dominique Heaggan-Brown found not guilty in fatal shooting

MILWAUKEE -- A Milwaukee County jury has found former Milwaukee police officer Dominique Heaggan-Brown not guilty in the 2016 shooting of Sylville Smith, whose death sparked several nights of violence in the city's Sherman Park neighborhood.

The jury announced their decision shortly after 2:00 p.m. Wednesday. 

On August 13, 2016, officers chased Smith on foot after he ran from a traffic stop near 44th and Auer. Heaggan-Brown shot first, firing a bullet at Smith, and striking him in the arm.

The second and fatal shot was fired after Smith tossed his gun and dropped to the ground. It happened less than two seconds after the first. Smith's shooting triggered several nights of violence in Milwaukee's Sherman Park neighborhood. Local businesses and cars were vandalized, set on fire, and destroyed, causing millions of dollars in damage.Shory

Shortly after the verdict was issued, Milwaukee Police Chief Ed Flynn released the following statement:

The jury’s verdict was based on the objective evidence before it.  A year ago I told the public I’d seen nothing in the video that was a violation of the law or policy.  The jury saw the same evidence and came to the same conclusion.

Dwight Lovett from the League of Martin, an organization of African-American police officers, issued the following statement after the verdict:

This is what we expected based on training and experience as current and former members of the police department. Viewing the footage, based on training and experience, I did not see anything the officer did wrong.

Several people were charged for looting. So far there have been no charges in the series of fires.

The key piece of evidence in the case was never-before-released police body camera video, both from Heaggan-Brown and another officer on the scene.

Prosecutors from the state wrapped up their case last Friday after calling several witnesses, including crime scene agents from the Department of Justice. Those agents walked the jury through video of the chase and shooting.

The defense called just one witness, an expert on police procedures and use of force. 

Heaggan-Brown's attorneys took less than a day before resting their case. Heaggan-Brown chose not to testify.

Print this article Back to Top